July 22, 2026

The Real Cost of Emptying the House: Estate Sales, Online Auctions, Buyouts, and Auction Houses, Compared

Imagine you are standing in the front hall of a house that has been lived in for forty years. The dining room holds a table that seated twelve at holidays. The china is in the breakfront where it has always been. Upstairs there are closets no one has opened in a decade, and a basement with tools, boxes, and a workbench. None of it is going with you. All of it has to go somewhere, and someone is going to quote you a price to make that happen.

Before you take any of those quotes, it helps to know two things: what the contents are actually worth on today’s market, and what each way of selling them will cost you. The second question is where most of the money is decided, and it is the question almost no one lays out plainly. Here it is, assembled from the people who do this for a living.

First, the honest question: is it worth selling at all?

Not everything in the house has a buyer, and the market right now is unusually blunt about which things do. Traditional dining sets, sideboards, and secretaries — what the trade calls “brown furniture” — have fallen out of fashion, and formal dinner services and heavy ornate crystal are especially hard to sell now, according to Antique Trader’s 2025 reporting. These were the aspirational purchases of one generation and are of little interest to the next, and price follows demand.

There is a reason the softness is showing up now. A large generation is downsizing and settling estates at the same time, and a great deal of household property is coming to market at once. When supply climbs like that, ordinary things get cheaper, and the pieces that hold their price are the genuinely scarce ones. This is the wave you are selling into. It does not mean the house is worthless. It means you should find out what is truly good — a real period piece, a signed work, precious metal by weight — and be unsentimental about the rest, because the cost of selling ordinary goods can easily exceed what they bring.

Route one: the in-home estate sale

How it works. A company prices and stages the entire contents in the house, advertises to its buyer list, and runs a public sale over a weekend. You hand over the keys; they do the labor.

What it costs. This is the expensive convenience. Estate sale companies typically charge 30 to 50 percent of gross sales, most commonly in the 35 to 45 percent range, according to EstateSales.org and EstateSales.net. In an operator survey compiled by EstateSales.org, a 45 percent rate was the single most common answer. Additional charges for cleanout or trash-out of what doesn’t sell are common on top of the commission. To make the commission concrete: at a 45 percent rate, a sale that grosses $10,000 returns $5,500 to you before any cleanout fee — the company keeps $4,500. That is arithmetic, not a quoted figure, but it is the arithmetic worth doing before you sign. These commissions are not fixed by law; they are set by local competition, and a large house or an unusually good one can move the number, so it is worth asking.

Timeline. Days to a few weeks: an assessment, a period to price and stage, then a one- or two-day sale.

Good for. A full house of saleable everyday goods where you want the whole thing handled and cleared quickly, and you accept a large share going to the operator in exchange.

When you hire, insist on: a written contract that states the commission percentage plainly, names every additional fee (cleanout, staging, advertising, credit-card processing), and says what happens to unsold items and who pays to remove them. Ask for a settlement statement itemizing gross sales against the commission, and ask when you will be paid.

Route two: the online auction

How it works. Two models sit under this heading, and the difference is more than logistics. In the ship-to-platform model — EBTH is the familiar example — the company collects your things and sells them from its own warehouse and national website; the contents leave the house, which suits an empty or already-vacated property and spares you strangers coming and going. In the in-place model — MaxSold is the familiar example — the auction runs from your house, with buyers bidding online and collecting in person on pickup day; it saves the cost of moving everything but means the house must be occupied or secured while lots are viewed and hauled out. Which one fits often comes down to whether anyone is still living there and how you feel about pickup-day traffic.

What it costs. On curated online estate-sale platforms such as EBTH (Everything But The House), the seller’s take-rate has been reported at around 30 to 40 percent by Kiplinger — meaning the platform’s share is the majority of the sale. MaxSold, which runs in-place online auctions, charges a commission on gross sales; its rate varies by auction type and is not published as a single uniform figure, so ask for the number in writing before you commit. Online take-rates are more standardized than estate-sale commissions and move less, but it never hurts to raise the question. The reach is wider than a local weekend sale, which can help unusual items find a buyer, but the cut is real and the low opening bids common to auctions mean ordinary lots may close cheaply.

Timeline. A week or two to catalog and photograph, a bidding window of several days to a week, then a scheduled pickup.

Good for. Mixed contents with some genuinely collectible or unusual pieces that benefit from a national audience, and a seller comfortable with auction-style pricing where the market sets the number.

When you hire, insist on: the exact commission rate in writing, clarity on who photographs and lists, whether there are lot minimums or listing fees, how and when funds are remitted, and what happens to items that receive no bid.

Route three: the buyout

How it works. A dealer or clearing company walks the house and offers a single lump sum for some or all of the contents, then hauls it away. You get one number and a clear house, often within days.

What it costs. There is no published rate here, and that is the point to understand. A buyout price is a private offer, set by what the buyer expects to resell the goods for minus their labor and risk, and it is discretionary. That makes it the fastest route and, on ordinary contents, often the one that returns the least, because the buyer has to profit on resale and absorb whatever doesn’t sell. A buyout also rarely covers the true dregs — the buyer takes what has value and may leave the rest — so whatever remains still has to be cleared, and that is its own separate cost. Here it is worth knowing exactly which service you are buying. A full-service senior move manager, who handles the whole relocation — planning, packing, sorting, and coordinating the move itself — is a different job from simply hauling away what’s left. Industry reporting on senior move management puts those full-service managers at roughly $40 to $100 per hour, with a complete move commonly running $3,000 to $10,000 or more; the National Association of Senior & Specialty Move Managers keeps a member directory if you want to compare firms in your area. Basic debris or junk removal — clearing out whatever no one bought — is a narrower and usually cheaper line item, and it should be quoted on its own rather than lumped in with a managed move. When a buyer leaves the dregs behind, get that haul-away priced separately so you know what you are paying to finish emptying the house.

Timeline. The fastest of the four. An offer on the spot or within a day, removal shortly after.

Good for. Speed and finality — an out-of-town executor, a firm closing date, a house that has to be emptied on a schedule and where maximizing the return matters less than being done.

When you hire, insist on: a written offer that states exactly which items are included and which are not, whether removal and cleanout are part of the price or billed separately, and a firm removal date. Get more than one offer; because the number is discretionary, a second bid is your only real gauge of whether the first is fair.

Route four: the traditional auction house

How it works. A consignment auction house takes individual pieces of real value, catalogs and markets them to collectors, and sells them under the hammer. This is for the good pieces, not the contents of the garage.

What it costs. The seller’s commission is commonly 10 to 25 percent of the hammer price, sliding lower as the value of the consignment rises. Industry reporting puts the largest houses near 10 to 20 percent under $50,000, and 5 to 10 percent for property in the $50,000 to $200,000 range; those are reported benchmarks rather than fixed rates, negotiable at the top end, and Heritage Auctions publishes consignment information along these lines. There is a second number that matters to what you ultimately net: the buyer pays the house a buyer’s premium of roughly 20 to 25 percent on top of the hammer price. On a $1,000 hammer, that is another $200 to $250 the buyer has to pay to take the piece home — arithmetic on the 20 to 25 percent range, not a quoted fee. Buyers know this, so they bid with the premium in mind, which effectively holds down the hammer price — meaning the premium comes, in practice, out of the realized value of your item.

Timeline. The slowest route. Consignment, cataloging, and placement into the right themed sale can take weeks to months, followed by settlement after the auction.

Good for. Individually valuable pieces — a period antique, a signed work, fine jewelry, a coherent collection — where reaching the right collectors justifies the wait and the commission is a small share of a large number.

When you hire, insist on: the commission schedule in writing for your value tier, any additional charges (photography, cataloging, insurance, unsold-lot fees), the reserve on each lot, and the settlement timeline. For a serious piece, get a second opinion on the estimate before consigning, because the estimate shapes the reserve and the marketing.

The four routes, side by side

Set against one another, using only the figures and timelines above, the four routes divide roughly like this:

A framework by the shape of the estate

The right route depends less on the house than on what is actually in it.

Mostly ordinary household goods. If the contents are everyday furniture, kitchenware, and the depressed categories — brown furniture, formal china, collector plates — the commission on an estate sale or online auction can consume much of a modest return, and a buyout may net little after the cleanout. Weigh the money against your time. Sometimes the plain calculation is that clearing the house cheaply and donating the rest beats paying a large percentage to sell goods the market has moved past.

A few good pieces in an ordinary house. Pull the genuinely valuable items out and treat them separately. Send the real piece to an auction house or a curated online platform where it can find a collector, and handle the ordinary remainder with whichever clearance route is cheapest and fastest. Do not let a whole-house estate-sale commission fall on the one item that was carrying the sale.

A serious collection. If there is real depth — a coherent collection, fine jewelry, precious metal, period antiques — the auction house is built for exactly this, and on large numbers its sliding commission is the smallest bite of the four. Get more than one estimate, understand the reserves, and be patient. This is the case where waiting pays.

What we would do

The route that empties the house fastest and the route that returns the most are almost never the same route, and the costliest mistake we see is paying a maximizer’s commission on goods that were only ever going to clear. So we would be clear with ourselves early about which problem we actually have — a few things worth selling well, or a house that mostly just needs to be empty — and choose the route to fit that, rather than hiring a high-commission service in the hope that ordinary contents will somehow beat a market everyone in the trade quietly agrees is soft. The people who end up disappointed are almost always the ones who bought the expensive route expecting a return the goods could not produce. Decide in advance what your own time is worth, name the number you would trade for being finished, and let that — not the hope of a windfall — settle the route. That is the honest trade, and making it on purpose is the whole of the skill.

Next in this series, the letter turns to the question that comes before any of these quotes: how to find out what your things are actually worth, so that when a company names a price you already know whether it is a fair one.

Some links in this guide may be referral links. If you use one, we may earn a fee at no cost to you. Fees never decide what we recommend. Read our full disclosures.